Homemade Spicy Cheddar Cheese Spread Recipe

There's something irresistible about a creamy, zesty cheese spread that makes crackers, vegetables, and sandwiches come alive with flavor. Today, I'm sharing my favorite homemade cheese spread recipe that combines sharp cheddar and pepper jack for a bold, satisfying snack that's perfect for everything from casual gatherings to game day celebrations. For this Spicy Cheddar Cheese Spread recipe, I adapted our Hot Pimento Cheese Recipe. It's another amazing cheese spread that you will want to try!

Read more: Homemade Spicy Cheddar Cheese Spread Recipe

Why Make Your Own Cheese Spread?

Store-bought cheese spreads are convenient, but they often lack the complex flavors and fresh ingredients that make homemade versions truly special. When you create your own cheese spread, you control the heat level, the texture, and most importantly, the quality of ingredients. Plus, this easy cheese spread recipe comes together in minutes, making it a practical choice for busy home cooks.

The Perfect Balance of Flavors

This particular cheese spread recipe starts with a foundation of sharp cheddar cheese, which brings a rich, tangy base flavor that cheese lovers crave. The addition of pepper jack adds another layer of complexity and a subtle heat that works beautifully with the other ingredients. By using freshly shredded cheese instead of pre-packaged options, you'll achieve a smoother, more flavorful result in your finished spread.

The secret to making this cheese spread truly memorable lies in its blend of pickled peppers. The combination of jalapeños and banana peppers provides both heat and tanginess, while their pickled nature adds a bright, acidic note that cuts through the richness of the cheese and mayo. Green onions bring a fresh, crisp element that lightens the entire dish and adds visual appeal.

Making Your Cheese Spread

The beauty of this shredded cheese recipe lies in its simplicity. Start by ensuring your cheeses are well-shredded and at room temperature for the smoothest blending. In a medium bowl, combine 4 ounces of shredded sharp cheddar and 4 ounces of shredded pepper jack cheese. Add a half cup of mayonnaise, which serves as the binding agent and adds extra creaminess to your spread.

Next, fold in a quarter cup of chopped pickled jalapeños and banana peppers. The variety of peppers creates a more interesting flavor profile than using just one type. Add three stalks of finely chopped green onions, mixing them throughout the spread for bursts of fresh flavor in every bite.

A half teaspoon of sugar might seem unusual in a cheese spread recipe, but it helps balance the heat and tanginess of the peppers. Season with salt and pepper to taste, keeping in mind that the cheeses already contain some salt. For those who enjoy extra heat, a teaspoon of Sriracha or Frank's Red Hot sauce can be stirred in at the end.

Serving and Storage Tips

This homemade cheese spread is incredibly versatile. While it makes an excellent cheese spread for crackers, don't limit yourself. Try it spread on bagels for breakfast, use it as a sandwich filling, or serve it with fresh vegetable crudités for a healthier option. It can even be heated slightly to create a warm, dippable consistency perfect for tortilla chips or crusty bread.

For the best flavor, refrigerate your cheese spread for at least two hours before serving. This allows the flavors to meld together and the texture to firm up slightly. When stored in an airtight container, this spread will keep well in the refrigerator for up to a week, though it rarely lasts that long in most households!

Customizing Your Spicy Cheddar Cheese Spread

One of the best things about making your own cheese spread is the ability to customize it to your taste. If you prefer more heat, increase the amount of jalapeños or hot sauce. For a milder version, substitute the pepper jack with Monterey Jack cheese. You could even experiment with different varieties of cheese, though the sharp cheddar provides an important flavor foundation that shouldn't be completely eliminated.

Tips for Perfect Cheese Spread Every Time

For the smoothest texture in your cheese spread, shred your own cheese rather than using pre-shredded varieties. Pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking agents that can affect the texture of your spread. Additionally, bringing the cheese to room temperature before mixing will help everything blend together more easily.

When incorporating the mayonnaise, start by mixing it with the shredded cheese before adding other ingredients. This creates a smooth base that will better incorporate the peppers and onions. If you find the spread too thick, you can add a little more mayonnaise, one tablespoon at a time, until you reach your desired consistency.

Whether you're looking for an easy cheese spread recipe for your next party or just want to elevate your daily snacking, this spicy cheddar cheese spread delivers incredible flavor with minimal effort. It's proof that sometimes the simplest recipes, made with quality ingredients and a little love, are the most satisfying.

So next time you're in the mood for a cheesy snack, skip the store-bought options and try this homemade cheese spread instead. Your taste buds – and your guests – will thank you for it!

Watch Me Make this Spicy Cheddar Cheese Spread

If you enjoyed this post please consider leaving me a FIVE STAR review, like and comment! I truly appreciate all of your comments!

See in you in the next on!

-Sarah