Homemade banana pudding flavor in a CAKE ya’ll! What could be more southern than that? If you can make a box cake, you can make this cake. Banana Pudding Poke cake is EASY!
Why This Recipe Works...
- Easy
- Delicious
- Incorporates Mamaw's Banana Pudding and flavors of Banana Bread all in ONE!
Here's How It's Done...
STEP 1.
Make a cake per the box instructions...
STEP 2.
Poke holes in the cake, prepare the pudding and spread it on top.
STEP 3.
Place the banana disks on top
STEP 4.
Spread Cool Whip over the top and sprinkle with crumbled Nilla Wafers
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ's) about Banana Pudding Poke Cake
What Is a Poke Cake?
A poke cake has holes poked in it and then something (pudding in this case) is poured into the holes. This makes the cake exceptionally moist and WONDERFUL!
Enjoy Bananas? Try this Best Homemade Southern Banana Pudding Recipe (Easy)!
Can I Use a Different Flavor of Pudding?
SURE! I recommend the vanilla but a banana flavor works too or even a pistachio flavor would work!
The bananas you put on the cake will give it a banana flavor.
Can I Leave Off the Banana Slices?
Absolutely! That said, you'll definitely need to use banana flavor pudding though or there won't be any banana flavor.
Will It Help If I Use the Cook Pudding and Put It On Warm? Can I Use a Cook and Serve Pudding Instead?
- Cook and serve pudding is OK to use, however, add it WARM and not hot.
- Do not add the bananas or the cool whip until the entire cake and pudding mix have cooled to at least room temperature.
- Really though, it will save you time to just use the instant and it works best that way too.
Can I Make a Sugar Free Banana Pudding Poke Cake?
The answer is Yes and No. If you can find Sugar Free Cake Mix, Sugar Free Whipped Cream and then use the Sugar Free Pudding, you are home free!
Can This Cake Be Made The Day Before?
Absolutely, put it in the fridge to keep it as fresh as possible.
Can I freeze this Banana Pudding Poke Cake?
Yes, you CAN! Do not add the whipped cream or bananas or crunchy cookie topping until ready to serve. Put those together after you remove the cake from the freezer.
Here's how...
- Stop at step two.
- Poke the holes in the cake
- put the pudding in the holes and on the cake.
- Wrap the cake very well with wax paper followed by plastic wrap in several layers.
- Place in the freezer and will keep for 3 months.
- When removing from the freezer allow it to come to room temp then you can add the bananas and cool whip.
Here's a great article from the USDA about freezing and food safety!
How To Store Banana Pudding Poke Cake.
Keep your banana pudding poke cake in the fridge.
Can I Make My Own Whipped Cream Instead of Using Cool Whip?
Here's what I do:
- 2 Cups Heavy Cream (chilled)
- 4 teaspoon sugar
- 1 teaspoon real vanilla extract
- 2 Tbs sour cream
- Chill the bowl of the stand mixer in the freezer for at least 20 minutes.
- Add the chilled cream to the chilled bowl and using the whip attachment, whip on a high speed until the cream thickens to consistency I desire.
- Turn the mixer off, add the sugar, vanilla and sour cream and then turn on a very low speed.
- Mix until the additional ingredients are well incorporated.
PRO TIP: The sour cream acts as a stabilizer and will help the whipped cream not become runny or watery.
Can I Make This Into Banana Pudding Poke Cake Cup Cakes?
Yes, you can!
It should make about 12-18 depending on how full you fill your cup cakes.
You'll need to adjust the baking time, but the side of your cake box will tell you how to do this for cupcakes.
Poke about 4 holes in the cup cake, but not more or it will become unstable.
Can I Make This with a Gluten Free Cake Mix?
Yes, absolutely!
- If you have a gluten free cake mix, go for it.
- However, be careful to look at the size cake it makes.
- The rest of this recipe is for a 9x13 size cake and you may need to adjust your other ingredients accordingly.
TIPS AND TRICKS FOR BANANA PUDDING POKE CAKE
- Cook the cake slightly under done - so if the cakes calls to be cooked for 22 minutes - cook it for 20. This allows you to poke the holes without messing up the cake too much.
- Poke a lot of holes in the cake.
- Pour the pudding as soon as you make it - when it is still a tiny bit thin.
- Use RIPE bananas for the most flavor - the greenish ones cut better but the riper ones have more banana flavor.
- Use as many vanilla wafers as you want for the topping - you are the king in your kitchen!
- Change up the topping with chopped pecans or walnuts.
PRO TIP: Dip the banana slices in a mix of 2 Tbs of lemon juice and 1 Tbs of water to keep them from browning too quickly.
Banana Pudding Poke Cake
Ingredients
- 1 Yellow cake mix cake made by the package instructions
- 2 boxes of INSTANT vanilla pudding - made by the package instructions
- 3 ripe bananas cut into disks
- 1 12 oz tub of whipped cream type topping thawed to room temp
- 10 vanilla wafer cookies smashed into crumbles
Instructions
- Make the cake according to package instructions in a 9x12 baking dish.
- Make the two boxes of pudding according to package instructions.
- Cut the 3 bananas into disks.
- Poke holes into the cake at regular intervals (see the process photos) and then pour the pudding onto the cake. Using a spatula, spread the pudding out over the cake and push as much of the pudding into the holes as possible.
- Place the banana disks onto the pudding.
- Cover the banana disks with the whipped cream topping and spread it out.
- Sprinkle the vanilla wafer crumbs over the top.
- Refrigerate and serve chilled.
Notes
- Allow the cake to cool a little before poking holes.
- This serves the same number of people regardless of it being a layer or sheet cake, but is probably slightly easier to serve to a crowd as a sheet cake.
- Cook the cake slightly under done - so if the cakes calls to be cooked for 22 minutes - cook it for 20. This allows you to poke the holes without messing up the cake too much.
- Poke a lot of holes in the cake.
- Pour the pudding as soon as you make it - when it is still a tiny bit thin.
- Use RIPE bananas for the most flavor - the greenish ones cut better but the riper ones have more banana flavor.
- Use as many vanilla wafers as you want for the topping - you are the king in your kitchen!
- Change up the topping with chopped pecans or walnuts.
- PRO TIP: Dip the banana slices in a mix of 2 Tbs of lemon juice and 1 Tbs of water to keep them from browning too quickly.
- PRO TIP: Feel free to use something besides vanilla wafers on the top. Maybe try crushed pistachios, pecans or walnuts!
Nutrition
***This recipe first appeared on Loaves and Dishes on May 17, 2017 and has been updated with "why this recipe works', step by step photo instructions, FAQ's, nutrition information, equipment information and video***
A VERSE TO SHARE
Have you ever felt like you have so much to do that you will NEVER get it all done? Yeah, me too. All the time. Every. Single. Day.
That is just my day to day life. Add work on top of that. Add family obligations on top of that. Add….. add anything else on top of that and I’m just overwhelmed.
I know, you get that way too.
I think it's important to remember something - remember who has your back. You aren’t in this alone. Even if you WERE in it alone, you still wouldn’t be in it alone.
That’s how powerful our Lord’s game is. I mean, come on, if He made heaven and earth - surely my little stuff isn’t too much, right? Right!
Says so right here…
Leave a Reply