Skip to Content

Four Cheese Pasta Bake


I have actually dreamed about this Four Cheese Pasta Bake. Yeah, I know. That little statement probably gives you some insight into stuff you might not really want to know about me and my slightly junky and cookbook filled brain. Unless you have plopped yourself down in a comfy restaurant booth after a long day when the weather is gray and rainy and your mental forecast looks just as dim and enjoyed a similar dish to this, you can’t imagine the comfort and relief that comes with that first hot and creamy bite of Four Cheese Pasta Bake. Am I telling too much? Probably. I usually do. But, if you are like me, sometimes you need a dish that is promised to be hot in your belly and delicious on your tongue in ways that can’t be compared to anything else! I hope you will hang with me here for a recipe that will send you to comfort food heaven.

It is time for the recipe express lane. If you want to know the tips and tricks for this recipe or if you want to talk more about the essence of comfort food, or if you want to know where I’ve been and why this is the first and only recipe this week, then please hang on with me through the recipe and a few pictures and we will chat. For you recipe seekers, Here you go….

four cheese pasta bake

four cheese pasta bake


four cheese pasta bake

Four Cheese Pasta Bake

A delicious and creamy pasta that will fill all your desires for comfort food immediately!  
5 from 2 votes
Print Pin Save Rate
Course: main
Cuisine: American
Keyword: 4 cheese pasta dinner, adult macaroni and cheese
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 30 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Calories: 330kcal


  • 1 lb of Penne Pasta cooked per box instructions
  • 1 stick of unsalted sweet cream butter
  • 1 clove of garlic minced
  • 1 8 oz block of cream cheese - cut into one inch blocks
  • 1 Cup grated Parmesan Cheese the real kind is best
  • ½ Cup grated Fontina Cheese
  • ½ Cup grated Gruyere Cheese
  • 1 Cup of cream
  • Salt and pepper to taste


  • Preheat oven to Broil. Cook pasta per package instructions and only cook to the al-dente level. You want a little spring in your pasta.
  • In a medium sized sauce pot on top of the stove over medium heat, melt the one stick of butter. Allow the garlic to be in the sauce pan while the butter melts. When the butter starts to bubble a little - allow it to bubble for a minute before adding any other ingredients. Once the butter has bubbled for a minute, you may add all of the other cheeses and the cream all at once. Stir frequently until all of the cheese melts. It will take a while for the cream cheese to melt - just be patient, it will get there. Stir often so that cheese do not burn or stick to the bottom of the pan. The melted cheese should be the consistency of a thick egg nog. If you are finding that it is too thick, add a little more cream or you can substitute milk.
  • By the time the cheeses are melted well, the pasta should be done. Drain the pasta and take the cheese off of the burner. Place single servings of the pasta into individual sized baking dishes or into large ramekins. Pour the sauce over the noodles so that each dish receives an equal amount of cheese. Use a fork and move the noodles around to ensure that the sauce coats all of the noodles. Sprinkle Parmesan over the top and place in the oven under broil. Allow to broil for a minute or two until the top becomes slightly brown and bubbly. Remove from the oven and serve immediately with a crusty italian style garlic bread and a fresh green salad. You may garnish with green onion or parsley.


Choose the best cheese you can for this recipe because it makes for the most intense flavor.
Browning the top is important as this ads a tiny crunchy and a delicious flavor. 


Nutrition Facts
Four Cheese Pasta Bake
Amount Per Serving
Calories 330
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Tried this recipe?Mention @loavesanddishes or tag #loavesanddishes!
Extreme Pasta comfort food is found in this cheesy pasta dish right here. Add chicken or shrimp to make it even better! Italian Cheese and baked till piping hot! YUM!

Extreme Pasta comfort food is found in this cheesy pasta dish right here. Add chicken or shrimp to make it even better! Italian Cheese and baked till piping hot! YUM!

Tips and Tricks for FOUR CHEESE PASTA BAKE

  • It takes some time for cream cheese to melt – so, don’t get your panties in a wad over it. Just know – it takes time. You can soften it in the microwave first if you want – that usually helps. You can help it along by mashing it some with a wooden spoon as it heats in the pan – that usually helps too. Sometimes it is still a little lumpy and a firm whisking can help – takes out your aggressions anyway.
  • You will want the sauce to be slightly thinner than what you think it should be before putting it in the oven – the oven thickens it a tiny bit.
  • Serve this dish PIPING HOT – as in crackling and sizzling. It is good as a left over but nothing beats it hot out of the oven. Especially if you have had a bad day.


This recipe is inspired by the Four Cheese Formagi that is served up piping hot at my local Piccolo Milano’s restaurant in Walnut Cove, NC. Seriously, if you have a chance, try it out. YUM! Hands down, favorite dish there! But – I can’t always go to Piccolo Milano’s and thus, I had to figure out my own recipe! This is as close as I could get.


I don’t even want to tell you this. Some stuff came up this week that got in the way of the blog. I beg your eternal mercies and goodness! I know I mentionedl that I was going last weekend to see  my near life long girlfriends! I did and we talked and ate and talked and ate and then we did a little shopping and then we talked and ate some MORE! I was delighted to share THIS recipe with my friends when Heidi and I cooked on Saturday night for the crowd.

Here is a picture that my friend Laura took of us with her “selfie stick”. Anyway, you will remember Laura from THIS POST. (PHOTO CREDIT – LAURA B LYNCH!)

All the Girls

Then, on Monday it was my precious and valued day off ( I am so lucky to be able to keep my beloved grandbaby on my Monday off). Instead of cooking up a few things for the blog and taking pictures of food while I watch the baby, I took pictures of the baby himself!!! Don’t you love tiny hands and feet?? So precious!

four cheese pasta bake

Baby hands and a blue plastic egg!

four cheese pasta bake

Tiny Bunny foot slipper!

Look I have TOES!

My normal work day routine is to jump up out of the bed  drag myself from under the covers WAY early in the morning and cook and write. My sweet hubby laughs when he gets up at 5:30 and I already have three things coming out of the oven and the photo studio is burning bright. He says that the light is so bright that it looks like a space shuttle is taking off in there. This week though, I just couldn’t get up at 4 am. I ran out of gas.

Then, on Wednesday, we TREKKED more than 2 hours from home in search of a Craigslist deal. And WOW! I got a great deal! I can’t wait to show you the results of that deal! I went looking for a new lens for my camera and ended up with a new lens AND a new camera! So excited!

Hopefully, we will all be enjoying those photos in coming posts. I do have to admit though, in researching the camera, I am now drooling over the Nikon D4s or the new flagship D5. Maybe one day. 

For now though, we will just enjoy our Four Cheese Pasta which soothes the ragged soul – not kidding. One bite, soul soothed. For me anyway. How about you? Is there a food out there like that for you? I know my sweet hubby feels that way about the Chocolate Pie – you can find that recipe HERE.  My youngest daughter feels that way about anything with White Sauce on it – you can find that recipe HERE. Tell me all about your comfort food, I want to know!!! Chat me up in the comment section – you can find that down on the bottom of the page here and we can swap stories of ragged days. Lol. Thanks for reading!

Wendi is the writer, CEO and dishwasher at Loaves and Dishes! When not in the kitchen or behind the computer, you can find Wendi serving on International Food Conference Boards, Speaking at various conferences, Leading and Cooking for the local Arts Council's "Taste of Stokes" events or donating home cooked goodies to various local non profits such as the Danbury Songwriters and Stokes Partnership for Children. Wendi is also a Registered Nurse with a Master's Degree and serves on her town's board of councilmen.

Recipe Rating


Friday 8th of June 2018

Can you freeze this dish

Wendi Spraker

Friday 8th of June 2018

Hi Connie. I have never frozen it so I can't really say. My guess is yes, but it may not end up the same consistency.


Friday 2nd of February 2018


Pamela Buchanan

Monday 14th of March 2016

YUM!! Love mac and cheese!

Wendi Spraker

Tuesday 15th of March 2016

Nothing better than Mac and Cheese!!


Saturday 12th of March 2016

My friend, you were sorely missed! This recipe makes the wait worthwhile. Hot melty cheese = pure perfect comfort. OH!, those precious baby pictures....adorable feet and hands! Love the bunny foot. Grandbabies are worth missing a blog post. Good luck with your future camera buying. Although, I have to say your photos are lovely!!! Pinned. After reading your normal weekday are appreciated even more!!!! Thanks for sharing.

Wendi Spraker

Saturday 12th of March 2016

Hi Mary!!! Never fear - I'm right here. :). I have a couple pretty good recipes coming up this week. I'll be making one tomorrow and doing the photography - trying out my new camera. Pretty excited about that! It will show up on the blog Monday. It's an ice cream based recipe!! YUM!!!


Want My 9 Secrets to Immediate Kitchen Confidence?